Add weight when it fits the purpose of your programme and your recent performance supports the change. Add repetitions when there is still useful room within the agreed range. Repeat the same task when the comparison is unclear. A harder workout is not automatically a better next step.

The useful question is specific: “What should change in this exercise next time, and why?” Start with the prescription you already have, rather than choosing a heavier weight because another week has passed.

Compare the same task

A record of ten repetitions means more when you know the exercise setup, range of movement, rest and effort involved. Ten repetitions with a different seat position or shorter movement are not a clean comparison with last week's eight.

Use your strength-training log to keep those details beside the load. You do not need to record every possible variable. Record the ones that would change the decision.

If you are trying an unfamiliar exercise, first use the starting-weight guide. Choosing an initial load and progressing an established exercise are different tasks.

Three records, three next questions

Imagine that an adult and their coach have agreed three sets in an eight-to-ten repetition range, with consistent movement and an agreed effort target. The following records are fictional. The range and set count illustrate an existing prescription; they are not instructions for everyone.

Completed record What it tells us Next decision to discuss
Eight repetitions in each set, with the agreed setup and effort There may be room to progress within the existing repetition range Keep the load and discuss adding repetitions while preserving the task
Ten repetitions in each set, repeated under comparable conditions and within the agreed effort target The upper end of this prescription has become repeatable Discuss the next available load increment and how repetitions may change
Ten, eight and six repetitions after cutting the rest periods More than one part of the task changed Restore a useful comparison before treating the result as a reason to increase load

These are discussion points, not automatic pass marks. The coach may have a reason to retain the same work, including the wider programme or the purpose of that training block.

Check the size of the next step

Equipment can make progression less tidy than a spreadsheet suggests. The next dumbbell may represent a substantial jump for a particular exercise. A machine may offer a smaller change.

Before adding weight, check what the actual increment is. Do not assume that the next item on the rack is the right next prescription. Keeping the load while improving repeatability or progressing within the agreed repetition range can be a useful option.

My recommendation is to make the intended change clear. If you add weight, add repetitions and shorten the rest together, it becomes harder to understand the result. A deliberate change gives the next record a clearer purpose.

What does the research support?

The ACSM's 2026 overview of resistance-training research concerns healthy adults and emphasises matching training to individual goals and circumstances. Its discussion distinguishes obtaining benefits from exercise from pursuing continued progress over time. It does not establish a rule that every successful session must be followed by a load increase.

That distinction matters. Maintaining a useful routine and trying to improve a particular lift are different goals. Neither is served by adding weight without knowing what the change is meant to achieve.

The table above is an original coaching aid. It is not a tested progression algorithm, and the research does not validate its fictional numbers as universal thresholds.

Write the next decision before leaving

Complete one short row:

  • Task: exercise, setup and agreed repetition range.
  • Result: completed work and reported effort.
  • Comparison: what stayed the same and what changed.
  • Next step: repeat, add repetitions or discuss a load increase.
  • Reason: the observation that supports that choice.

For example: “Same row setup and rest; ten repetitions in each set on two comparable visits; effort stayed within the agreed target. Discuss the next load increment with the coach.” This records a reason, not a demand to lift more regardless of how the next session goes.

If new pain or another health concern affects the exercise, do not use a progression table to clear yourself to continue. Seek appropriate advice.

For help making these decisions within your programme, bring two comparable exercise records to personal training at Tempo in Fitzrovia. The next step should be something you can explain, perform and review.